You mean
Spider? Yes, it was a very well made morbid drama and a look at schizophina which was deeply memorable. Its not a horror film, one of Cronenberg's few non-horror movies actually. Its visually quite profound and the story doesn't treat you like an idiot as is customary these days.
Comparison to Season of the Witch is way to ludicrous for me, even though i understand Spider might not be everyone's cup of tea, its completely different film. Compare Seasons of the Witch to an earlier low budget Cronenberg, and I'd take shivers, the brood or rabid.
As far as I see their careers, Cronenberg's films have been of a extremely high standard since Shivers (I'm not familiar with his earlier movies), Romero's career is all over the place, ranging from really crap to genre defining. Argento's is even more all over the place, but I don't recall seeing a good Argento for a long time, imo obviously.
Here's the list of director's credits, cronenbergs even done more, even if you remove all the tv movies/series.
Cronenberg:
# A History of Violence (2005)
# Spider (2002)
# Camera (2000/III)
# eXistenZ (1999)
# Crash (1996/I)
# M. Butterfly (1993)
# Naked Lunch (1991)
# "Scales of Justice" (1990) TV Series (episode "Regina vs Horvath")
# Dead Ringers (1988)
# The Fly (1986)
# The Dead Zone (1983)
# Videodrome (1983)
# Scanners (1981)
# The Brood (1979)
# Fast Company (1979)
# Rabid (1977)
# "Teleplay" (1976) TV Series (episode "The Italian Machine")
# "Peep Show" (episode "The Lie Chair") (episode "The Victim")
# Shivers (1975)
# Scarborough Bluffs (1972) (TV)
# Fort York (1972) (TV)
# In the Dirt (1972) (TV)
# Winter Garden (1972) (TV)
# Don Valley (1972) (TV)
# Lakeshore (1972) (TV)
# Jim Ritchie Sculptor (1971) (TV)
# Letter from Michelangelo (1971) (TV)
# Tourettes (1971) (TV)
# "Programme X" (1970) TV Series (episode "Secret Weapons")
# Crimes of the Future (1970)
# Stereo (1969)
# From the Drain (1967)
# Transfer (1966)
Romero:
# Land of the Dead (2005)
# Bruiser (2000/I)
# The Dark Half (1993)
# Due occhi diabolici (1990)
# Monkey Shines (1988)
# Day of the Dead (1985)
# Creepshow (1982)
# Knightriders (1981)
# Dawn of the Dead (1978)
# Martin (1977)
# O.J. Simpson: Juice on the Loose (1974) (as George Romero)
# The Crazies (1973)
# "The Winners" (1973) TV Series
# Hungry Wives (1972)
# There's Always Vanilla (1971)
# Night of the Living Dead (1968)
Argento:
# "Masters of Horror"
- Pelts (2006) TV Episode
- Jenifer (2005) TV Episode
# Ti piace Hitchcock? (2005) (TV)
... aka Do You Like Hitchcock? (International: English title)
# Cartaio, Il (2004)
... aka The Card Player (International: English title) (USA)
... aka The Card Dealer
... aka The Cardplayer (Australia)
# Non ho sonno (2001)
... aka Sleepless (Europe: English title) (USA)
... aka I Can't Sleep (promotional title)
# Fantasma dell'opera, Il (1998)
... aka Dario Argento's The Phantom of the Opera (UK: video title)
... aka Phantom of the Opera (USA: video box title)
... aka The Phantom of the Opera (USA)
# Sindrome di Stendhal, La (1996)
... aka Stendhal's Syndrome
... aka The Stendhal Syndrome
# Trauma (1993)
... aka Dario Argento's Trauma (USA: complete title)
# Due occhi diabolici (1990) (episode "The Black Cat")
... aka Two Evil Eyes (USA)
# Opera (1987)
... aka Terror at the Opera (USA)
# Phenomena (1985)
... aka Creepers (USA)
# Tenebre (1982)
... aka Sotto gli occhi dell'assassino
... aka Tenebrae
... aka Under the Eyes of the Assassin
... aka Unsane (USA)
# Inferno (1980)
... aka Dario Argento's Inferno
# Suspiria (1977)
... aka Dario Argento's Suspiria (USA: promotional title)
# Profondo rosso (1975)
... aka Deep Red
... aka Deep Red Hatchet Murders
... aka Dripping Deep Red
... aka The Hatchet Murders
... aka The Sabre Tooth Tiger
# Cinque giornate, Le (1973)
... aka The Five Days (USA: literal English title)
... aka The Five Days of Milan
# Tram, Il (1973) (TV) (as Sirio Bernadotte)
... aka Porta sul buio: Il tram, La (Italy: series title)
... aka The Tram (International: English title)
# Testimone oculare (1973) (TV) (uncredited)
... aka Eyewitness (International: English title)
... aka Porta sul buio: Testimone oculare, La (Italy: series title)
# 4 mosche di velluto grigio (1971)
... aka Four Flies on Grey Velvet (USA)
... aka Four Patches of Grey Velvet
... aka Quatre mouches de velours gris (France)
# Gatto a nove code, Il (1971)
... aka Chat à neuf queues, Le (France)
... aka Neunschwänzige Katze, Die (West Germany)
... aka The Cat o' Nine Tails (USA)
# Uccello dalle piume di cristallo, L' (1970)
... aka Bird with the Glass Feathers
... aka Geheimnis der schwarzen Handschuhe, Das (West Germany)
... aka Phantom of Terror
... aka Point of Terror (USA: alternative title)
... aka The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (USA)
... aka The Gallery Murders
So based on that, I'm compelled to continue to reallocate the points to cronenberg, despite Romero being an excellent director in the past and him making some of my favourite movies.
